I decided I need to put this out in the public because I need to say it out loud to help myself. I grew up a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. I graduated from Seminary, and I was a member of the Seminary Council my senior year in high school. I met President Russell M. Nelson when I was in the 9th grade, and I felt the spirit and power that he carried with him. I attended Ricks College (BYU-Idaho) and traveled as a member of the folk dance team where I was able to meet with prominent leaders of the church prior to touring in 1994 and 1995 with the team. I served a mission for the LDS church in Oakland, California from 1996-1998 where I was blessed to learn the Spanish language and grew to love the Latino culture. When I returned from my mission, I graduate from BYU, and I married Victor in the Salt Lake Temple in 1999. I served in the primary as a teacher, counselor, or chorister from 1999 to 2023. When Victor quit going to church, I still went. I felt that the church was true, and everyone else that was not a member was wrong.
However, prior to Tommy's birth in 2012, Elder Dallin H. Oaks gave a talk in General Conference about the LGBTW community, and he condemned them for being who they were. I quit watching conference at that time. When Tommy was born, Victor wanted to give him his name and a blessing in church. Our bishop at the time told Victor he couldn't do it because he did not hold a current temple recommend. We had to show the bishop in the church handbook that a temple recommend was not required for a father to give his child a name and a blessing. Victor gave Tommy the blessing, but he has not returned to church since then except to support me a few times when I spoke in Sacrament meeting or when we had the Primary Program each year.
The year the the City Creek mall was built, Victor quit paying tithing because he found that the church had used the majority of the money to build the mall from tithing funds. I still kept paying tithing because I firmly believed that it was being used for the homeless and to relieve suffering for those who were not as fortunate as we are.
In 2017, I asked Victor, Rachel Amanda, and VJ to attend Trek with me in Wyoming where we were able to walk the same paths that our ancestors walked when they came across the plains with Brigham Young and the early pioneers. I have a great-grandmother buried in Scotts Bluffs, Nebraska who died while crossing the plains, and when the railroad came through, they discovered her grave, and they moved the railroad lines so as not to disturb her burial spot. Her grave has since been moved, but they have erected a monument there for her that I was able to visit in 2021 and feel a little of the suffering that she must have experienced. In 2021, we also visited Carthage Jail and Nauvoo, Illinois. We were able to see the bullet holes in the jail where Joseph Smith and Hyrum Smith were martyred. We were able to see the Nauvoo Temple, and I felt the spirit as we were there and in the cemetery of Nauvoo where Victor has relatives buried with no burial markers.
However, in 2023, the news came out that the church had been hiding over $32 billion in securities, and they had been investing in companies that only existed on paper. I had been paying over $6,000 a year in tithing just on my income alone since 2012. I paid over $60,000 to the church from 2012 to 2023, and I learned in 2023 that my tithing wasn't being used for what I thought it was being used for. I thought my money was helping to build temples, build churches, fund humanitarian relief efforts, provide education for children from other countries or even children in the U.S. who couldn't financially afford an education. I was a benefit of these funds when I attended college since I received scholarships and traveled with the dance team at ridiculously low costs. I was sick to my stomach when I learned that the church had billions hidden, and I saw that there is still so much suffering in the world.
Around the same time, the church made a statement/policy that if a person was not heterosexual then their family should basically cut them off and not have anything to do with them. The church has since gone back on that policy, but I couldn't feel good about the thought of never speaking to a friend or family member because of their sexuality. I kept asking, What if one of my children were gay? Would I be able to cut them off? My answer was always a NO!
This past fall, the church once again came out with a policy about transgender people, and they stated that transgenders cannot hold callings or go to a restroom in a church alone. This was the final straw for me. I know people in the church who have been bishops and in stake presidencies, and they are supposedly "good" people, but they also cheated on their wives and abused children. Just because a person is transgender does not mean they are a pedophile!
So, I haven't gone to church since 2023, and it's still weighing on my mind. I still believe in Jesus Christ and Heavenly Father. I still believe that we can live eternally one day, and I believe that Christ is our Savior and Redeemer. What I don't believe in is a God who chooses which of His children we should or should not love. I do not believe in a God who asks members to pay tithing so that his prophets and leaders can invest those funds for their own personal benefits. I do not believe in a God who would tell parents that they cannot love their child because that child is homosexual or transgender. I do not believe in a God who would have all of the money that the LDS church has and not use that money to help the suffering.
I also do not believe in a God who changes His doctrine as He sees fit. In the early days of the church, polygamy was doctrine, but not all members of the church lived that doctrine. I cannot find any polygamy in my parents' lines, and remember, I have ancestors who crossed the plains with Brigham Young. I have always told Victor that I could never live polygamy, and I still feel that way. If polygamy means I will not be in the highest degree of the Celestial Kingdom, then I don't want to be there.
In the early days of the church, Black people were allowed to hold the Priesthood. But then Brigham Young became prophet and it was no longer allowed. In the 1970's the church changed that and said it was modern day revelation. I was taught growing up that Black people were descendants of Cain, and therefore, they were not worthy of holding the Priesthood. I am thankful the doctrine changed, but I don't see why it was ever doctrine in the first place.
I was also taught growing up that we would one day be Gods and Goddesses and be able to create our own worlds. In the Temple, I was promised that if I lived up to the covenants I made, I would one day be a Goddess, Queen, and Priestess who would rule with my husband over our own worlds for eternity. Now, if you look up the church's teachings, that isn't the case. We can live eternally with our families, but we will not be Gods and Goddesses.
Another doctrine that has changed is the idea that homosexuality was a choice. As I grew up, I was taught, it was a person's decision whether or not they were gay. If they were gay, then they were evil. I never felt good about that doctrine. Then about a decade ago, the church changed its teachings, and they said people are born gay, but they shouldn't act on it. What kind of God would create someone who is gay and not allow them to act naturally? What kind of God would put His children through the torment of loving a person of the same sex but not being able to show that love?
Two recent things that have really been bothering me is the changing of the garments. When I was growing up, my mom wouldn't even allow me to wear tank tops that covered my whole shoulder. I remember fighting with her in high school because I wore a tank top a friend loaned to me that covered my shoulders, and I bought one with money I earned and wore throughout my senior year. When I entered the temple and started wearing garments, I was grateful that it wasn't a big adjustment for me since I had always worn shorts to the knee and rarely wore that tank top that covered my shoulders. I judged people who did not wear the garment properly, and I couldn't believe it when I saw people my own age who chose to not wear them so they could exercise without the garment on. I even wore my garments when I clogged! I was taught you only took them off for sex and swimming. The last few years when the church emphasized that we should wear the garment as instructed, I nodded my head and said, "Here! Here!' Imagine my surprise in October the church announced that they were changing the garment again. There will now be a cap sleeve garment top for those in hotter climates and a slip version for women. What? I wore the garments in the Dominican Republic in 2019 when the temperature was over 100 degrees. I wore the garments in Utah in the summer when the temperature was over 100 degrees. I wore the garments in California when the temperature was over 100 degrees. But now, since the church has had modern day revelation, we are going to have garments that are more comfortable for those who live in hotter climates.
Finally, I recently learned that when the church started, one of the teachings was that children who were mentally disabled were the way they were because they were followers of Satan. Yet, when I was growing up, I was taught these children were those who fought Satan in the pre-Earth life and their disabilities are a protection for them during their Earth life. I cannot imagine my son, VJ, being a follower of Satan. He is the most loving and perfect person I know!
So, to bring it all to an end, I'm struggling. I have a lot of questions. There are a lot of other things I haven't talked about here that I also have questions about. Don't even get me started about the Book of Mormon and how it supposedly is about the Native Americans, but now it isn't necessarily about the Native Americans. My sister-in-law and I have talked about all of this, and she keeps reassuring me that it will all work out in the end, and so I keep reminding myself that it will all work out in the end.
To those of my friends who are members of the Church, I love you! I'm grateful for you and the Church. The teachings of the Church are what made me who I am today. They gave me the values and beliefs that I have today, including the belief and we are ALL God's children, and we are supposed to LOVE ONE ANOTHER and JUDGE NOT LEST YE BE JUDGED. I love going to the gardens at Thanksgiving Point and walking through the statues that portray Christ's life and teachings. I love singing and hearing spiritual music. Most of all, I try to love everyone just like Jesus taught. I have students who are part of the LGBTQ+ community, and I love them. I want nothing more for all of us than to live peacefully together and hopefully be together in the life after this. However, I will not be attending church in the near future because there are just too many contradictions for me to believe that this is the one true church. If I am wrong, then I am wrong, and I hope that the God I love and believe in loves me enough to forgive me and not send me to a burning hell because I truly believe that God is our Father, and He loves us unconditionally.